African American Female College Students Talking about Career Development
by Angela D. Coker
Have you thought about the way people often talk about their careers?
"I want my career path to be on the fast track"; "I'm a square peg in a round hole"; "It's a roller-coaster ride"; "I feel I'm on a plateau"; "I need to change gear"; What I do is a legacy from my father."
Such statements are exercises in metaphor - the substituting of physical or dramatic images for the abstract concept of "career." There is not a real "path" or "roller-coaster" or "peg" or "plateau" or "gear" or "legacy", yet these are excellent shorthand representations of the way that the speakers think about their careers. We know exactly what they mean. Metaphor is natural - psycholinguists and cognitive psychologists advise us that we do much of our thinking in metaphors (Ortony, 1993).
Metaphors can constrain our career thinking. Obsessing about one's career being a journey along a narrow uphill path to the top of a mountain, or about finding the "perfect fit" between self and job, may prevent us from seeing our careers in novel ways. Correspondingly, deliberately searching for new metaphors for career may enable us to liberate ourselves from stereotyped ways of thinking, and to perceive fresh opportunities.
Archetypal metaphors for career are that the career is an inheritance, a cycle of different seasons of life, an action or construction, a search for fit, a journey, a series of roles, a developing network of relationships, a resource, and a story. Both the thinking of people pursuing their careers, and the theories promulgated by academics and taught to aspiring career practitioners tend to cluster around these core metaphors (Inkson, 2004).
The most common metaphor of career - embodied in words such as "path", "track", "plateau", "ladder", "progress", "climb", "destination", "compass", and "map" - is that of the journey. Asked to use a metaphor to summarize their careers, over 50% of people use a journey metaphor. But journeys can be of many different types - goal-directed or autonomous, upwards or up-and-down, local or international, fast or leisurely. Different forms of the journey metaphor provide rich material for individuals to question their thinking about their careers, or for counselors to encourage them to think outside their current frame.
Career practice is likewise assisted but also constrained by metaphors. Assessment-oriented practitioners tend adopt the "fit" or "match" metaphor, seeking to learn more about their clients and about the opportunities available in an attempt to find a good fit between the two. Developmental psychologists see careers as exercises in growth. Those with concerns for work-life balance focus, and get their clients to focus, on the competing demands of different work and non-work roles, and the conflict between them. Company managers are interested in developing employees' careers as resources from which the organization can benefit. All may benefit by thinking about "multiple metaphors" that go beyond the constraints of their own favored ways of perceiving the world (Inkson, in press).
There is growing interest in the use of metaphor in counseling (Lyddon, Clay & Sparks, 2001). This can be extended to career counseling (Amundson, 1998; Inkson & Amundson, 2002; McMahon, in press). Advocates use as a base metaphor the notion of the career as a story, a personal narrative account of the career based on the client's own self-construction of his or her identity. The "truth" of the story is less important than what it reveals about the client's thinking. Frequently the story will have a metaphorical basis which can be used by the counselor to stimulate new thinking.
In an example, a client reported how her career journey had become like a car "stuck in the sand." That prompted a productive dialogue about the nature of the car, the journey and the sand, and the various strategies which might be adopted: rope-and-tackle? send for a tow-truck? get out and walk? stay there? Some counselors use physical drawings of the metaphor to assist visualization. The client's own metaphor can thus be used to assist him or her to get a new appreciation of the situation and possible actions. Alternatively, the counselor can suggest alternative metaphors to encourage new insights and career planning by the client.
The new interest in metaphor is part of a "post-modern" view of careers - one in which flexibility, creativity and personal narrative play a part, enabling the development of wider and more imaginative views of career behaviour and practice. The new approaches do not deny the utility and value of conventional methods of career development, based on rational theory, assessment, information and decision making. In good practice, metaphor supplements traditional approaches rather than attempting to replace them.
I have used metaphor to provide the framing of a forthcoming textbook on careers (Inkson, in press, see forthcoming announcement on www.sagepub.com ), including a chapter on metaphor and counseling by a career counselor colleague (McMahon, in press). I invite dialogue with interested persons.
Amundson, N. E. (1998). Active engagement: Enhancing the career counselling process. Richmond, Canada: Ergon Communications.
Inkson, K. (2004). Images of career: nine key metaphors. Journal of Vocational Behavior, 2004, 65, 1, 96-111.
Inkson, K. (in press). Understanding careers: The metaphors of working lives. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA..
Inkson, K., and Amundson, N. (2002). Career metaphors and their application in theory and counseling practice. Journal of Employment Counseling, 39, 3, 98-108.
Lyddon, W. J., Clay, A. L., & Sparks, C. L. (2001). Metaphor and change in counseling. Journal of Counseling and Development, 79, 269-274.
McMahon, M. (in press). Metaphor and career counseling. In K. Inkson, Understanding careers: The metaphors of working lives. Sage Publications, Thousand Oaks, CA.
Ortony, A. (1993). Metaphor and thought (2nd ed.). Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Dr. Angela D. Coker, Ph.D., LPC, NCC, is an assistant professor in the Division of Counseling and Family Therapy at the University of Missouri - St. Louis. She received her Ph.D. in Educational Psychology and Counseling from the Union Institute and University, her M.S. in Counselor Education from the University of Wyoming, and her B.A. in Liberal Arts from Brooklyn College. Dr. Coker’s research agenda includes race, gender, and class issues in counseling. She is a licensed professional counselor and a national certified counselor. She can be reached at email@example.com